ḤeshbonCenter on Data and Jewish Life Sources Where to start
HESHBONColleges and Universities
2026-27 Edition · Published September 2026
Special Report

Best Graduate School Cities for Observant Families

48 university cities and 24 graduate programs, including ten PhD fields, scored on seven things a married student couple weighs: how far the campus is from a shul community, rent for a two-bedroom that becomes a three-bedroom, the depth of the observant community, a Jewish preschool, a JCC, kosher food, and the strength of the program.

Pick a program and move the weights. Rent uses HUD FY2026 Fair Market Rents for every metro so the cities compare on one scale. The size of each observant community comes from Heshbon's own shul ratings where we have them and from shul counts elsewhere. Anything marked est is an estimate or was not source-checked.

Best all-round cities

We scored every city for all 24 programs at our default settings and gave badges to the three with the highest and most consistent results. The badges stay with these cities when you change the settings below. Open any card to see why it won.

St. Louis

First in 14 of its 22 programs · never below 8th · average score 84

Why the award?

St. Louis comes first in 14 of the 22 programs it offers, more than any other city, and it never falls below eighth. Rent is the lowest of the three at about $1,393 a month, 22% of a $75,000 household income, and both Washington University campuses are a short walk from a shul. Bais Abraham is 0.3 miles from the main campus and Chabad of the Central West End half a mile from the medical campus. The city also has an eruv, a JCC and six Jewish preschools near a shul, including an observant one.

What to know The community is small, with 8 observant shuls and 9 certified kosher eateries. We could not confirm that Chabad of the Central West End holds a regular minyan. Our data has no economics PhD or dental school for the city, and its lowest finish is eighth, for an education PhD.

Pittsburgh

Top five in 23 of 24 programs · first in 5 · average score 83

Why the award?

Pittsburgh has all 24 programs and makes the top five in 23 of them, coming first in economics, education, computer science, mathematics and speech pathology. Pitt and Carnegie Mellon sit beside Squirrel Hill and Shadyside, so the nearest shul is under a mile from either campus, and rent averages about $1,480 a month, 24% of income. It also has an eruv, a JCC and six Jewish preschools near a shul, including an observant one.

What to know The community is mid-sized, with 13 observant shuls and 8 certified kosher eateries. The closest shul to both campuses is Chabad of Shadyside, and we could not confirm that it holds a regular minyan. Its lowest finish is ninth, for law school.

Chicago

Top five in 18 of 24 programs · never below 7th · average score 81

Why the award?

Chicago has all 24 programs and never ranks below seventh. Chabad centers sit on or beside the University of Chicago, UIC and the Illinois Medical District, and the city has strong schools in almost every field. Behind that stands one of the largest observant communities in the country, with about 89 shuls, an eruv and 24 certified kosher eateries, nearly all of them in West Rogers Park, Skokie and Lincolnwood.

What to know Rent is the highest of the three, about $2,038 a month or a third of income. Hyde Park has three shuls and no certified kosher eatery outside the university dining halls, and the main community in West Rogers Park is a long commute from Hyde Park and the medical district.

Ranked for medical school

Each city's score is out of 100. Under every number is the share of points it earned, such as "15 of 20 pts", and the stripe beside it darkens as the city earns more of them. Click a city to read what life there would be like, see the map of shuls around campus, and find out where it lost points. The three BEST badges mark the best all-round cities described above, and the small number under each badge is its place in the list you are looking at. Pin up to four cities to compare them side by side.

    Where the program is strong and the rent is bearable

    How each score is built

    Shul near campus. Straight-line miles from the nearest observant community shul to the nearest edge of the campus where the program is taught, with campus outlines from OpenStreetMap and geocoded shul addresses. Half a mile or less scores 100, one mile 75, two miles 50, five miles 5, six or more 0. Student-only minyanim are shown but not scored. Where no campus outline exists the distance runs from a central building less 0.4 miles, marked est.

    Rent. Average monthly rent across the program, two-bedroom until the year you choose, three-bedroom after, divided into your household income. Twenty percent of income scores 100 and sixty percent scores 0.

    Size of the observant community. For the 23 cities that also appear in Heshbon's Jewish community affordability index (DASI), we use that index's 0 to 100 rating of shul life. For the rest, we estimate the rating from the number of observant shuls, using the pattern in those 23 cities (score = 38.0 + 10.4 × ln(1 + shuls), n = 23). An eruv adds 15 percent.

    Preschool. 328 Jewish early-childhood programs found and geocoded across the 48 cities. The score is 70 percent the best program type within three miles of a community shul (observant 100, Chabad 90, community 80, JCC 75, Conservative 65, Reform 55) and 30 percent how many there are. JCC is present or not. Kosher food counts restaurants, take-out, pizza, cafés and bakeries certified by an observant agency (OU, OK, Star-K, cRc, Kof-K or the city's observant vaad) within about 20 minutes of the main observant neighborhood, recounted in September 2026. Caterers, supermarket counters, ice cream and candy shops, hotels, stadiums and campus dining halls are not counted. The score earns nothing for five places or fewer and rises with the log of the number of kosher eateries up to eighty, plus 15 for a kosher grocery or supermarket department.

    Program. Each list uses the best-ranked program in the metro on the current U.S. News list for that field, read from U.S. News in September 2026. A #1 program scores 100, falling evenly to 15 at the bottom of the list. Medical school uses the 2026 research tier (Tier 1 = 100, Tier 2 = 80, Tier 3 = 62, Tier 4 = 45). Schools that no longer submit data are estimated from the parent university's rank, capped at 92. The medical schools we count as the Elite 8 (Harvard, Johns Hopkins, Penn, Stanford, Columbia, Duke, NYU and UCSF) also decline to take part, and we give them full marks. The ten PhD fields use the U.S. News graduate rankings for each field, and the shul distance runs to the campus of the school with the best program in that field. U.S. News shows biomedical engineering ranks only for its top 14 programs, so other biomedical engineering programs are estimated from the school's overall engineering rank and marked est. "Other field" uses the national university rank as a stand-in. Dental schools have no national ranking and all score 70. Health programs measure shul distance to the medical campus. Speech pathology, social work, psychology and the MBA use the main campus. Residency uses the same medical score as a proxy for the academic medical center, since residents are placed by the Match rather than admitted.

    What this does not show. Market rents near campus run well above HUD's metro figures in Manhattan, Boston, Palo Alto and Toco Hills. Preschool tuition was found for only a handful of cities. Safety, commuting by transit, and spousal job markets are not scored.

    Photo credits

    Campus photos are from Wikimedia Commons, used under the licenses listed. Photos marked CC BY-SA may be reused under the same license. No photo was available that fit for Teaneck (Hackensack Meridian) or Kansas City (KU Medical Center).

      Ḥeshbon

      A data project on how Jewish life is paid for, published in full. Every figure comes from the underlying research, and where a chart simplifies a published result the piece says so.

      Each piece here is published, with its own sources, sample sizes and limits stated in place. Percentages describe the samples observed, and several rest on small denominators, noted where they appear. Nothing here audits an individual institution. Aliyah figures are current as of August 2026, at roughly three shekels to the dollar, and Israeli tax and benefit rules move faster than that.